As for the acolytes who surround the Antler Queen, those might be easy to guess, too. Natalie (or Lottie, if she’s not the queen), Shauna, Misty, Taissa, and Van have all embraced the ritual of the hunt, and Travis seemed to be on his way in the finale when he took a bite out of his brother’s heart. These are the seven main characters who are still kicking and still a part of the group in the ’90s plotline, which leaves just a small handful of potential victims — the teammates whose present-day counterparts we haven’t met yet.
This group includes Coach Ben (Steven Krueger), Akilah (Nia Sondaya), Mari (Alexa Barajas), Gen (Mya Lowe), and Melissa (Jenna Burgess). If we’re feeling hopeful, we could also include Crystal/Kristen (Nuha Jes Izman), who fell off a cliff this season but whose body was never recovered. She’s almost certainly dead, though, and the list of possible pit girl candidates narrows down from here. Coach Ben obviously isn’t a teenage girl, and the victim in question has light skin, so she’s not Akilah. Melissa, a background character whose most memorable moment so far was when she and Gen schemed to eat Crystal/Kristen if they found her, also has blonde hair and seems unlikely to find some dye lying around the forest, eliminating her from the shortlist.